Zapatero’s Productivity Solutions
With price inflation running rampant, family savings in the dumps, private credit expansion sky-high and worker productivity in the red, the Spanish economy’s competitiveness is collapsing. The government doesn’t seem to know how to stop inflation, but for the past two years Moncloa has been advertising a state run plan to encourage R&D that will save our competitiveness. Can Moncloa really believe this?
According to the 2005 World Investment Report from the United Nations Committee on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), in 2004 13.2 percent of the 50 largest transnational companies made R&D investments in Spain. It isn’t great, but still nothing to sneeze at. And what about the future? How do those 50 companies, the largest on the planet and responsible for two-thirds of world business spending on research and development, view Moncloa’s plans? Well, not too enthusiastically. Only 1.5 percent consider Spain an attractive place to establish R&D activities between 2005 and 2009.
In this ranking of large investors, in which Spain has the dubious honor of sharing its position with Romania and Tunisia, China (61.8 percent) and the United States (41.2 percent) rank one and two respectively. These two show us that countries can indeed attract investment with low labor costs, but there is more. The United States ranking indicates that, while in absolute terms its labor costs are high, they don’t pose a problem if the economy is relatively free, open and productive. Europe’s out of control interventionism has managed to turn the United Kingdom into the only country in the region considered an attractive place to invest in R&D by more than 10 percent of multinational companies (13.2 percent).
Spain, following the European playbook on how to consolidate a un-welfare state, is trying to hide part of the growing productivity gap with the United States and other freer countries by spending taxpayer money on R&D. This administration is, once again, falling for the constructivist socio-economic myth. It doesn’t seem to understand the research and development that really contribute to improving productivity cannot be achieved through state-injected funds, but only by cutting red-tape, taxes and, of course, public spending. Absolute investment numbers in R&D don’t matter. The people’s needs are what matter. And those are best met if the investors find a free market and develop a project with their own resources. The government should stick to trying to end the monetary inflation it fosters and ensuring politicians leave us alone. Let the rest of us worry about innovative investment.
